Sureyya Burcu Avci (Sabanci University - School of Management), Cindy A. Schipani (University of Michigan, Stephen M. Ross School of Business), H. Nejat Seyun (University of Michigan at Ann Arbor), & Andrew Verstein (University of California, Los Angeles (UCLA) - School of Law) have posted INSIDER TRADING BY OTHER MEANS (Harvard Business Law Review) on SSRN. Here is the abstract:
For more than thirty years, one of the most prevalent strategies for insider trading has gone undetected and unaddressed. This Article uncovers the techniques by which executives and directors sell overvalued stock worth more than $100 billion per year, shifting losses to ordinary investors. The basic idea is that insiders conceal their suspicious trades by publicly reporting them (as they are required to do) in ways that confuse or discourage investigators. We develop a taxonomy of concealment strategies, complete with suggestive examples. We then empirically test our taxonomy using a database of essentially all stock trades since 1992. We find that insiders who trade using the subterfuges we describe outperform the market by up to 20% on average. Worse yet, we find evidence that this simple subterfuge works. Essentially no one has ever been prosecuted for undertaking one of these suspicious trades. Nor do journalists or scholars seem to appreciate them. Accordingly, we call for scholars and prosecutors to cast a wider net in their studies and market surveillance, then discuss implications for the design of insider-trading reporting requirements and related legal rules.